Material damage claims are less frequent in 2025, but their average cost is rising. More complex parts, structures specific to electric vehicles, and batteries whose repair costs can exceed the vehicle’s residual value mean that the premium alone is no longer enough to compare two car insurance policies. Deductibles, compensation limits and coverage exclusions matter just as much as—and sometimes more than—the quoted premium.
Average claim costs and deductibles: how the figures affect your choice of policy
A car insurance quote shows a monthly or annual price. That figure catches your eye, but it hides two factors that determine what you will actually pay in the event of a claim: the deductible and the compensation limit.
The deductible is the amount the driver has to pay after an accident. A low-premium policy with a high deductible can end up costing more than a slightly more expensive plan with a lower deductible, even after the first material damage claim.
| Policy feature | Impact on premium | Impact in the event of a claim |
|---|---|---|
| Low deductible | Higher premium | Lower out-of-pocket costs |
| High deductible | Lower premium | Higher out-of-pocket costs |
| High compensation limit | Higher premium | Better coverage for costly repairs |
| Low compensation limit | Lower premium | Risk of undercompensation for a recent vehicle |
As the average cost of repairs rises, particularly for vehicles equipped with sensors, cameras or laminated glass, a compensation limit that is too low can leave a significant gap between the payout and the actual repair bill. Checking these two details before comparing premiums helps avoid unpleasant surprises.
Figures published by comparison sites (such as Assurland, cited by Franceinfo) are average quotes by powertrain, not guaranteed prices. The quote you receive depends on the vehicle, where you live, your driver profile and the coverage you choose. These averages indicate market trends; they are not a benchmark for your personal budget.

Car insurance and electric vehicles: the battery as a financial risk factor
For an electric vehicle, the usual rule of thumb (new car = comprehensive cover, older car = third-party cover) does not apply so straightforwardly. Several points outlined in the insurance section on Auto World confirm that the powertrain affects pricing, but not consistently across insurers.
Data reported by Le Monde point to higher repair costs than for combustion-engine vehicles, particularly when the battery, windows or vehicle-specific structures are damaged.
The most frequently overlooked issue concerns a total-loss declaration. If an assessor determines that a damaged battery makes the vehicle uneconomical to repair, comprehensive accidental damage cover generally pays out the vehicle’s value. But if the battery is leased rather than purchased, it does not belong to the vehicle owner. The payout may therefore exclude the cost of the battery, creating a substantial gap between the car’s perceived value and the compensation received.
Coverage to check before taking out insurance for an electric vehicle
- Explicit coverage for the battery under the damage policy, including when the battery is leased, with the payout amount or calculation method specified
- A new-for-old or enhanced-value clause to offset the rapid depreciation of electric vehicles during their first few years
- Approved repair arrangements: some policies require you to use a repair network that may not always have the manufacturer certification needed to work on high-voltage batteries
Comparing quotes with equivalent coverage, rather than looking only at the premium, remains the only reliable way to assess the true cost of insuring an electric vehicle.
Cancellation after one year and continuous coverage: the risk of a gap in insurance
Switching insurers after the first year is a practical way to adjust your coverage or lower your premium. Under the law, the new insurer handles the cancellation process for motor third-party liability insurance and ensures that coverage continues without interruption.
The risk lies in a mismatch between the effective cancellation date and the start date of the new policy. Driving without insurance, even for one day, is an offence punishable by a fixed fine and licence suspension. Beyond the penalty, an accident during that gap leaves the driver personally liable for damage caused to third parties.
Before starting the cancellation process, make sure to check three things:
- Confirm that the new policy has been signed and that its start date coincides with the end of the previous policy, with no gap in coverage
- Check that your claims history and no-claims bonus/malus record have been sent to the new insurer, as a delay could affect the price or hold up the policy
- Make sure the new policy covers at least the same risks, so you do not unknowingly lose protection for glass breakage, theft or natural disasters

Third-party, intermediate or comprehensive cover: the often-overlooked factor
The choice between these three levels of coverage is usually based on the vehicle’s age and value. For a vehicle over eight years old with a low Argus valuation, comprehensive cover is rarely worthwhile if the annual premium could exceed its resale value.
The less obvious factor is personal accident cover for the driver. Third-party liability, which is mandatory under every policy, including third-party cover, pays for damage caused to others. It does not cover injuries to the at-fault driver. A third-party policy without driver cover leaves the driver without compensation if they cause an accident, even if they suffer serious, lasting injuries.
Adding this cover to an intermediate policy often costs less than upgrading to comprehensive cover solely to protect yourself against injury. Reading the policy line by line, with particular attention to this point, is what distinguishes suitable coverage from incomplete protection.
The premium influences your decision, but three clauses determine the coverage you actually get: the deductible, the compensation limit and driver cover. A policy with a low price that excludes the battery, caps compensation below the vehicle’s value or omits personal injury cover for the driver is no bargain. It is a gamble.



